Jagex Brings In The New Year With A Ban(g)


scaperune2

Arenanet isn’t the only one throwing cheaters overboard tied to a cement block. In a post released yesterday, the developer announced that users of a bot script would be logging in to find themselves permanently banned, among them long-time players:

As part of our ongoing war on botting, we continue to take action against those confirmed to be using a bot script. Just yesterday we banned a large number of bot users, including a number of maximum level players.

Additionally, in the same announcement Jagex detailed bans for an exploit in the recently released God Statues update which allowed players to generate a massive quantity of experience very quickly. Aside from banning the accounts that took part in the exploit, Jagex commented that they have also banned the alternate accounts of those same players.

(Source: RuneScape)

NCSoft Breaks Silence, Paragon Studios Wasn't Profitable


City of Heroes is undoubtedly the most surprising shut down of the year, not to mention the show of support for the game by its community during its last days.
City of Heroes is undoubtedly the most surprising shut down of the year, not to mention the show of support for the game by its community during its last days.

You didn’t think that the drama surrounding City of Heroes was over just because the servers had shut down, did you? Well think again. MMORPG.com has posted an article today detailing exchanges between NCSoft and a former Paragon Studios employee over the fate of City of Heroes, and as usual the two pieces of information directly clash with one another. According to the source from Paragon Studios, City of Heroes had been profitable even before the transition to free to play, bringing in twelve million annually compared to four million in operating costs. NCSoft apparently wanted $80 million to sell City of Heroes to another developer, however they valued the game at $3 million for tax purposes. Ultimately, however, the game was shut down as while the game was profitable, the profits were not “what they needed to be,” and Paragon wound up the weak link in NCSoft’s restructuring.

MMORPG.com asked for a comment from NCSoft, and received the following note from Lincoln Davis, Director of Corporate Communications:

“It is disappointing that such inaccurate information was provided to MMORPG by an anonymous source and is being reported on as news. The operating cost, annual revenue figures and other financial information shared by this anonymous source are simply wrong. The studio was unprofitable before the shutdown. Both NCSOFT and Paragon Studios were incredibly proud of the transition of City of Heroes to a Free to Play business model, but unfortunately it wasn’t enough to support the studio’s needs. We made the difficult decision to close Paragon Studios and sunset City of Heroes because the franchise no longer aligned with the long term profitability goals for the company.

“While we looked to sell the franchise multiple times, we were unsuccessful in finding a suitable partner that we thought would support City of Heroes’ fans in a manner they were accustomed to for years to come. Closing a studio and sun setting a beloved franchise is never an easy thing to do for the publisher, the developer or the fans. This was not an easy decision to make. The Heroes and Villains have taken to the skies of City of Heroes for the last time, but the game and community will remain in our memories. We truly thank our fans for their years of support and we hope they understand the difficult position we were in when making the final decision.”

I’d like to look at one particular node: Paragon Studios. Now, the anonymous source claims that Paragon Studios had another game in the works, a Lost meets Minecraft game, which means that Paragon was eating far more money than simply keeping City of Heroes optional. Lincoln Davis doesn’t say that City of Heroes was unprofitable, and one can only imagine that such a game wouldn’t consume three million dollars a quarter in upkeep alone. Rather, Lincoln Davis specifically states that “the studio” was not profitable, referring to Paragon Studios itself. It is entirely possible that while City of Heroes was profitable, the second project that Paragon Studios was consuming the rest of its revenue and then some, leaving the studio as a whole as a burden on NCSoft’s finances.

I should point out that the source was anonymous by request, meaning MMORPG.com presumably knows who they are talking to and that person is a credible source in the company. It is also important to note that this is the first time someone from NCSoft has commented directly that Paragon Studios was not making a profit, a comment that should have been made several months ago when Paragon Studios was first shut down. Despite the comment by Lincoln Davis, the latest entry into the City of Heroes saga once again leaves us with more questions than answers.

Was City of Heroes itself profitable? How much was this second project by Paragon Studios costing them to develop? Why didn’t Paragon just shut down the project since it was apparently breaking the bank? What was going on with this second game Paragon Studios was making? If the cost that NCSoft was asking for City of Heroes was not $80 million, as Lincoln Davis claims the figures were “simply wrong,” then how much were they asking for? If Paragon Studios was unprofitable due to these other projects, what kind of money were they losing every quarter? Who decided that shutting the game down now would be better than putting it into maintenance mode and simply ceasing development (like Microsoft recently did with Age of Empires Online)?

We will probably never get a complete answer on exactly what was going on at NCSoft and Paragon Studios that lead up to the shut down, but the statement by Lincoln Davis paints a pretty clear picture that the performance of Paragon as a studio and its other projects, regardless of how City of Heroes itself had been running, played a major part in the studio being shut down. There is an answer somewhere, and it is likely much more complicated than any of us will be able to figure out.

(Source: MMORPG.com)

NCSoft Breaks Silence, Paragon Studios Wasn’t Profitable


City of Heroes is undoubtedly the most surprising shut down of the year, not to mention the show of support for the game by its community during its last days.
City of Heroes is undoubtedly the most surprising shut down of the year, not to mention the show of support for the game by its community during its last days.

You didn’t think that the drama surrounding City of Heroes was over just because the servers had shut down, did you? Well think again. MMORPG.com has posted an article today detailing exchanges between NCSoft and a former Paragon Studios employee over the fate of City of Heroes, and as usual the two pieces of information directly clash with one another. According to the source from Paragon Studios, City of Heroes had been profitable even before the transition to free to play, bringing in twelve million annually compared to four million in operating costs. NCSoft apparently wanted $80 million to sell City of Heroes to another developer, however they valued the game at $3 million for tax purposes. Ultimately, however, the game was shut down as while the game was profitable, the profits were not “what they needed to be,” and Paragon wound up the weak link in NCSoft’s restructuring.

MMORPG.com asked for a comment from NCSoft, and received the following note from Lincoln Davis, Director of Corporate Communications:

“It is disappointing that such inaccurate information was provided to MMORPG by an anonymous source and is being reported on as news. The operating cost, annual revenue figures and other financial information shared by this anonymous source are simply wrong. The studio was unprofitable before the shutdown. Both NCSOFT and Paragon Studios were incredibly proud of the transition of City of Heroes to a Free to Play business model, but unfortunately it wasn’t enough to support the studio’s needs. We made the difficult decision to close Paragon Studios and sunset City of Heroes because the franchise no longer aligned with the long term profitability goals for the company.

“While we looked to sell the franchise multiple times, we were unsuccessful in finding a suitable partner that we thought would support City of Heroes’ fans in a manner they were accustomed to for years to come. Closing a studio and sun setting a beloved franchise is never an easy thing to do for the publisher, the developer or the fans. This was not an easy decision to make. The Heroes and Villains have taken to the skies of City of Heroes for the last time, but the game and community will remain in our memories. We truly thank our fans for their years of support and we hope they understand the difficult position we were in when making the final decision.”

I’d like to look at one particular node: Paragon Studios. Now, the anonymous source claims that Paragon Studios had another game in the works, a Lost meets Minecraft game, which means that Paragon was eating far more money than simply keeping City of Heroes optional. Lincoln Davis doesn’t say that City of Heroes was unprofitable, and one can only imagine that such a game wouldn’t consume three million dollars a quarter in upkeep alone. Rather, Lincoln Davis specifically states that “the studio” was not profitable, referring to Paragon Studios itself. It is entirely possible that while City of Heroes was profitable, the second project that Paragon Studios was consuming the rest of its revenue and then some, leaving the studio as a whole as a burden on NCSoft’s finances.

I should point out that the source was anonymous by request, meaning MMORPG.com presumably knows who they are talking to and that person is a credible source in the company. It is also important to note that this is the first time someone from NCSoft has commented directly that Paragon Studios was not making a profit, a comment that should have been made several months ago when Paragon Studios was first shut down. Despite the comment by Lincoln Davis, the latest entry into the City of Heroes saga once again leaves us with more questions than answers.

Was City of Heroes itself profitable? How much was this second project by Paragon Studios costing them to develop? Why didn’t Paragon just shut down the project since it was apparently breaking the bank? What was going on with this second game Paragon Studios was making? If the cost that NCSoft was asking for City of Heroes was not $80 million, as Lincoln Davis claims the figures were “simply wrong,” then how much were they asking for? If Paragon Studios was unprofitable due to these other projects, what kind of money were they losing every quarter? Who decided that shutting the game down now would be better than putting it into maintenance mode and simply ceasing development (like Microsoft recently did with Age of Empires Online)?

We will probably never get a complete answer on exactly what was going on at NCSoft and Paragon Studios that lead up to the shut down, but the statement by Lincoln Davis paints a pretty clear picture that the performance of Paragon as a studio and its other projects, regardless of how City of Heroes itself had been running, played a major part in the studio being shut down. There is an answer somewhere, and it is likely much more complicated than any of us will be able to figure out.

(Source: MMORPG.com)

Hellgate: Global Act 3 And Tokyo Are Now Completely Free


hellgate3

One of the issues that comes with working alone on my website is that occasionally I don’t come across news on games that are not frequently reported on until later. MUCH later in fact. Ever since Hellgate Global first reluanched under T3Fun, I’ve given an update on ticket prices every year or so. Tickets to Act 3 and the Tokyo Expansion were available for purchase on the cash shop for a combined total of approximately $7, while players could purchase and then sell them on the marketplace, making it entirely possible to play Hellgate’s content without paying a dime.

Granted, that alternative became extremely expensive. The Act 3 ticket was around 1.8 million palladium with the Tokyo expansion somewhere around 1 million last I checked in, making them more economical to just buy from the cash shop. In July 2012, however, T3Fun updated the game to make the tickets completely free:

As the forces of Hell ever grow stronger, more and more recruits are needed every day to help stave off the impending demon invasion of our world. Starting on July 5, 2012 (after regular server maintenance), the Act 3 and Tokyo Entrance Tickets will be given to all players at no charge.

So if you’ve been holding off playing Hellgate: Global because of having to pay for Act 3 and Tokyo, the good news is that you can pick up both tickets at the Greenwich Headquarters (first location) completely free.

Less Than 200 Banned For Guild Wars 2 Snowflake Exploit


guild-wars-2_83015

I hate writing articles on bans related to exploits, they just serve to confuse players and just those who found some interest in the article. Terms like “mass ban” and “widely exploited” are thrown around when the actual numbers of how many people were using the exploit, and consequently how many were banned for it, is much less impressive than the terminology surrounding the announcement. So let’s dive in and try to not confuse those of us who haven’t been playing Guild Wars 2 recently. I’m going to try to explain this the best I can, but don’t take the description of events below as 100% accurate. Ultimately all you need to know is what is quoted by Arenanet.

Wintersday is the event Arenanet holds in place of Christmas, and just like its real life counterpart, we can’t get through the holidays without someone getting stabbed (unless that’s just my family). According to what I’ve seen in news reports and from players, an exploit surfaced early on in the event which allowed players to use snowflakes from the event to convert several absurdly cheap items along with a black lion salvage kit, to generate endless amounts of ectoplasm, which is used in creating many of the high-level items. The exploit was closed and when Arenanet came back from holiday vacation, the team set off banning the worst of the offenders.

As I’ve already said, less than 200 were banned according to Arenanet. According to the North American Community Team Lead Regina Buenaobra, the banned players knew exactly what they were doing:

The number of accounts terminated as a result of this exploitative activity is actually very small—fewer than 200. However, these people are the very worst offenders, and engaged in this exploit to egregious levels—hundreds and even thousands of times. They knew exactly what they were doing and they knew that their activities would damage the economy.

Gaile Grey, Arenanet Support Liason, posted to explain why the exploit should have been obvious to anyone making use of it:

Any time you take one thing and can make two, and then four, and then sixteen… ya gotta know that’s just wrong. (I won’t quibble on the odds, but overall, that form of doubling was not outside the realm of possibility.) And to perform that action hundreds and hundreds of times? That’s call “exploitation,” and that’s against the User Agreement, the Rules of Conduct, and all that is holy.

(Source: GW2 Forums – Number banned)
(Source: GW2 Forums – Understanding Exploits)

Age of Empires Online Isn't Shutting Down, Content Development Ceases


age-of-empires-online-thumb

You like Age of Empires Online just the way it is, right? Hopefully you do, because Gas Powered Games has announced that future content development has ceased. A small amount of content will be released in the coming weeks, but after that Age of Empires Online will only see a few small changes to fix bugs as they crop up, as well as maintenance to keep the game running. Following this little bit of content, the game will be set as it is forever. Granted, this doesn’t mean that Age of Empires Online is close to shutting down.

Far from it in fact, rather Microsoft Studios notes in the announcement that nothing will change for current gamers:

However, nothing else changes for players, nothing that currently exists will be removed. You can still play everything you own, earn EP, and purchase any content you do not currently own. We will still fully maintain and support the game and its players; no one is losing anything that you have earned or bought. Our Community team will continue to support the game by way of Community Challenges, streams, contests, PvP tournaments and more.

The cause for the sudden cancellation is due to a reported high cost of developing content for the MMO.

(Age of Empires Blog)

Age of Empires Online Isn’t Shutting Down, Content Development Ceases


age-of-empires-online-thumb

You like Age of Empires Online just the way it is, right? Hopefully you do, because Gas Powered Games has announced that future content development has ceased. A small amount of content will be released in the coming weeks, but after that Age of Empires Online will only see a few small changes to fix bugs as they crop up, as well as maintenance to keep the game running. Following this little bit of content, the game will be set as it is forever. Granted, this doesn’t mean that Age of Empires Online is close to shutting down.

Far from it in fact, rather Microsoft Studios notes in the announcement that nothing will change for current gamers:

However, nothing else changes for players, nothing that currently exists will be removed. You can still play everything you own, earn EP, and purchase any content you do not currently own. We will still fully maintain and support the game and its players; no one is losing anything that you have earned or bought. Our Community team will continue to support the game by way of Community Challenges, streams, contests, PvP tournaments and more.

The cause for the sudden cancellation is due to a reported high cost of developing content for the MMO.

(Age of Empires Blog)

TERA Closer To Free To Play? En Mass Entertainment Shuffles Executives


TERA_ScreenShot_20120311_210446

With TERA going free to play in just about everywhere but North America, stateside fans are no doubt beginning to ask when their time is coming. The latest news from En Masse Entertainment was a post from Minea on the forums stating that TERA will remain subscription based in the United States. A definitive answer, one that sparked mixed reactions on the main forums with some players applauding the announcement and others not as satisfied.

With an announcement gone out today, En Masse Entertainment has revealed that Christopher Lee has been promoted to the position of Chief Executive Officer, replacing Dr. Jae Heon Yang who will step down and continue his role as an executive at En Masse Entertainment’s parent company Bluehole Studios. Mr. Lee was previously Vice President of publishing. Additionally, former Vice President of Nexon America Soo Min Park has been hired as Chief Operating Officer, replacing Patrick Wyatt who had left the company earlier in 2012 but still acts as an external adviser for the publisher. Halo Group Marketing Manager Bryan Koski has been hired to Director of Marketing while TERA Senior Producer Brian Knox will be promoted to Executive Officer.

What does this mean for TERA? Some might see the writing on the wall with hiring an ex-Nexon VP as Chief Operating Officer.

(Source: Games Industry International)

Jagex's Evolution of Random Events


scaperune2

I’ve always said that, despite its flaws and excessive grind, RuneScape has always been not only one of my favorite MMOs, but one that I’ve played continuously longer than any other title (I haven’t let my subscription lapse since 2005). For a game like RuneScape which is notorious for long, monotonous and repetitive actions, Jagex has gone in a direction over the past few years of shaking up the normal daily routine of its players, and that I feel deserves a pat on the back. I could use this space to discuss how Jagex has implemented various systems over the years to exponentially reduce the amount of clicking a player has to do to perform skills, but that is really just a small section of the improvements.

And thankfully I’m not talking about the obnoxious random events. Back in the early days of RuneScape, Jagex introduced random events that would either break or kill (and thus break) bot accounts. Random moments during skilling or combat would pop up, like a golem coming out and attacking your character or your pickaxe head flying off and needing to be picked up. It didn’t take long for bots to overcome these systems, and Jagex spent a few years desperately trying to think up new random events to beat the bots, all of which were quickly updated to counteract those measures. On the other hand, the random events were not a hindrance to bots, they were just an annoyance to legitimate players. Several of the random events were just plain broken, a couple were so difficult that players couldn’t complete them, and one was impossible to complete if you were color blind. On October 24, 2012, all random events were removed.

Technically speaking, the oldest Distraction and Diversions came years ago. Released in 2005, creatures from select species have the chance of dropping a scroll allowing the player to challenge the champion of that race to a one on one battle. The idea was there, however with a drop rate of one in five thousand (estimated), the odds are slim against players simply stumbling upon the scrolls. Another early distraction would be treasure trails. Many creatures in RuneScape have the chance of dropping clue scrolls, which requires that the player follow coordinates, decipher maps, and solve puzzles on a scavenger hunt to find loot from a randomized list. And finally, Tears of Guthix is a weekly mini-game where players collect items to obtain a small exp boost in their lowest skill.

In 2009, Jagex began using the term “distraction and diversion” in regards to what are along the lines of mini-games among mini-games. The distractions are meant to be small, often time locked activities to take part in during your normal gaming experience. For instance, a player might be chopping down trees and have a root pop up and knock them away. Further investigation would lead the player to an evil tree, which can be chopped or burnt to the ground alongside other players on the server in return for various experience rewards. Again, the idea wasn’t to introduce major game mechanics, but simply something to take the edge off of grinding or to provide a nice incentive for exploring around.

Since their release, Jagex has updated RuneScape with a growing variety of distractions and diversions, with their own quirks and timelines. Events can range from hourly to monthly, and involve everything from the player going on a hide and seek hunt for penguins, to donning a prosecutor/defense badge and making a stand in court. Some require the player to be in the right place at the right time, while others will simply fall into their lap during the course of regular game play. The events are short enough to not be a nuisance, fun enough to actually make the player want to take part, and unlike Jagex’s random events, the rewards are decent enough to warrant participating even if you don’t necessarily like the activity.

scaperune3

As with everything Jagex has done with RuneScape, and the same can be said for most other MMOs, new systems start off slow and evolve over time. So back in October I made a note to keep watch on a little update to RuneScape: Invasions. Introduced presumably as a way to test the technology, goblins now invade a random section of the game every half hour on the half hour. The update felt more like a prototype to be expanded upon than anything. The goblins are weak enough that even a new player could best them, and the rewards that they offer are among the lowest tiers of equipment. Still, I held out the hope that Jagex would eventually expand on the idea.

And expand they have. As per the January Behind The Scenes, the next invasion will be hitting RuneScape this month:

Similar to the goblin flash mobs from 2012 (only much, much tougher) you’ll be able to fight groups of NPCs that appear in pre-determined locations (like the Wilderness and other dangerous zones) throughout the world. For those brave enough, new rewards await! This time you’ll be able to kit yourself out with the latest in warrior-chic: the demon slayer armour. In addition to its generous stats – equivalent to dragon armour – they’ll also grant you increased XP when fighting demons, and an increased dodge chance when fighting the demon general that spawns at the end of the flash mob.demon flash mobs armour

Depending on where Jagex takes this, these events have the potential to spiral into something massive and game-changing. If anything, an increased variety of invasions would be a cool way to breath life into some of the lesser used areas of the world (of which there are many), not to mention expand on some of the game lore and throw a new feature into the game. Part of me would like to see this evolve into a system along the lines of Tabula Rasa, where players are tasked with defending villages and even cities from hordes of NPCs, with the possibility that the area could be ransacked and temporarily taken over should the players fail to defend the area, forcing them to retake the territory. Obviously this is wishful thinking and speculation on my part, but I think some form of PvE or even PvP territory control system (even if it is only present on certain worlds) would work great on RuneScape.

And with the RuneScape Next Gen coming, who knows?

Jagex’s Evolution of Random Events


scaperune2

I’ve always said that, despite its flaws and excessive grind, RuneScape has always been not only one of my favorite MMOs, but one that I’ve played continuously longer than any other title (I haven’t let my subscription lapse since 2005). For a game like RuneScape which is notorious for long, monotonous and repetitive actions, Jagex has gone in a direction over the past few years of shaking up the normal daily routine of its players, and that I feel deserves a pat on the back. I could use this space to discuss how Jagex has implemented various systems over the years to exponentially reduce the amount of clicking a player has to do to perform skills, but that is really just a small section of the improvements.

And thankfully I’m not talking about the obnoxious random events. Back in the early days of RuneScape, Jagex introduced random events that would either break or kill (and thus break) bot accounts. Random moments during skilling or combat would pop up, like a golem coming out and attacking your character or your pickaxe head flying off and needing to be picked up. It didn’t take long for bots to overcome these systems, and Jagex spent a few years desperately trying to think up new random events to beat the bots, all of which were quickly updated to counteract those measures. On the other hand, the random events were not a hindrance to bots, they were just an annoyance to legitimate players. Several of the random events were just plain broken, a couple were so difficult that players couldn’t complete them, and one was impossible to complete if you were color blind. On October 24, 2012, all random events were removed.

Technically speaking, the oldest Distraction and Diversions came years ago. Released in 2005, creatures from select species have the chance of dropping a scroll allowing the player to challenge the champion of that race to a one on one battle. The idea was there, however with a drop rate of one in five thousand (estimated), the odds are slim against players simply stumbling upon the scrolls. Another early distraction would be treasure trails. Many creatures in RuneScape have the chance of dropping clue scrolls, which requires that the player follow coordinates, decipher maps, and solve puzzles on a scavenger hunt to find loot from a randomized list. And finally, Tears of Guthix is a weekly mini-game where players collect items to obtain a small exp boost in their lowest skill.

In 2009, Jagex began using the term “distraction and diversion” in regards to what are along the lines of mini-games among mini-games. The distractions are meant to be small, often time locked activities to take part in during your normal gaming experience. For instance, a player might be chopping down trees and have a root pop up and knock them away. Further investigation would lead the player to an evil tree, which can be chopped or burnt to the ground alongside other players on the server in return for various experience rewards. Again, the idea wasn’t to introduce major game mechanics, but simply something to take the edge off of grinding or to provide a nice incentive for exploring around.

Since their release, Jagex has updated RuneScape with a growing variety of distractions and diversions, with their own quirks and timelines. Events can range from hourly to monthly, and involve everything from the player going on a hide and seek hunt for penguins, to donning a prosecutor/defense badge and making a stand in court. Some require the player to be in the right place at the right time, while others will simply fall into their lap during the course of regular game play. The events are short enough to not be a nuisance, fun enough to actually make the player want to take part, and unlike Jagex’s random events, the rewards are decent enough to warrant participating even if you don’t necessarily like the activity.

scaperune3

As with everything Jagex has done with RuneScape, and the same can be said for most other MMOs, new systems start off slow and evolve over time. So back in October I made a note to keep watch on a little update to RuneScape: Invasions. Introduced presumably as a way to test the technology, goblins now invade a random section of the game every half hour on the half hour. The update felt more like a prototype to be expanded upon than anything. The goblins are weak enough that even a new player could best them, and the rewards that they offer are among the lowest tiers of equipment. Still, I held out the hope that Jagex would eventually expand on the idea.

And expand they have. As per the January Behind The Scenes, the next invasion will be hitting RuneScape this month:

Similar to the goblin flash mobs from 2012 (only much, much tougher) you’ll be able to fight groups of NPCs that appear in pre-determined locations (like the Wilderness and other dangerous zones) throughout the world. For those brave enough, new rewards await! This time you’ll be able to kit yourself out with the latest in warrior-chic: the demon slayer armour. In addition to its generous stats – equivalent to dragon armour – they’ll also grant you increased XP when fighting demons, and an increased dodge chance when fighting the demon general that spawns at the end of the flash mob.demon flash mobs armour

Depending on where Jagex takes this, these events have the potential to spiral into something massive and game-changing. If anything, an increased variety of invasions would be a cool way to breath life into some of the lesser used areas of the world (of which there are many), not to mention expand on some of the game lore and throw a new feature into the game. Part of me would like to see this evolve into a system along the lines of Tabula Rasa, where players are tasked with defending villages and even cities from hordes of NPCs, with the possibility that the area could be ransacked and temporarily taken over should the players fail to defend the area, forcing them to retake the territory. Obviously this is wishful thinking and speculation on my part, but I think some form of PvE or even PvP territory control system (even if it is only present on certain worlds) would work great on RuneScape.

And with the RuneScape Next Gen coming, who knows?