Here at MMO Fallout, I have always taken the position that a developer’s previous work does not prohibit them from fixing what is broken or improving in future products. While we would like to see a world where games stop launching in a barely functional state, it stands to reason that any game can go from a failure to a success with a simple series of patches.
Nevertheless, it is a new day and that means another independent studio dead set on dragging their reputation through the mud by threatening a member of the games media. ODD Games has been making headlines with the news that the studio threatened Youtuber Nerd³ over his review of Monster Truck Destruction, a $5 mobile port currently sitting at a “mostly negative” rating on Steam with a peak of six users over the past month. Not a single person is playing it right now. The review video has been accused of making false statements about the game, at least in a manner of speaking.
Where the case gets interesting, and where the line gets drawn, is in timing. Factually speaking, nothing said in the original Youtube review was incorrect. Since the review was posted, however, ODD Games has patched Monster Truck Destruction and fixed several issues that were present in the build reviewed. In their threat, ODD Games demands that the video be taken down as the review “can be interpreted as defamatory.”
The letter goes on to give a 48 hour deadline before the issue is “escalated to the relevant authorities.”
Unfortunately for ODD Games, defamation doesn’t cover statements that were true at the time they were said but were later invalidated. It does, however, leave a mark on your company as being that one that uses threats and intimidation in order to get your way, and unsuccessfully at that. Just imagine how different these events might have played out had you simply sent an email asking for a fresher review? I can’t guarantee that your request would have been answered, but you can hardly do worse than this.
MMO Fallout 
